Scrum masters play a pivotal role in enabling agile teams to deliver value, but their effectiveness hinges not on formal authority, but on the power of influence and servant leadership.
The term “servant leadership” was first coined in the 1970s by Robert Greenleaf, and has since shaped modern agile practices by emphasizing empowerment over control.
Servant leadership provides the solution as you depart from command-and-control leadership to empower the people doing the work to make decisions. With formal authority, a scrum master would be viewed as a manager — someone to report to. Scrum masters should not be given formal authority but should rather be empowered by leadership to work with members of the scrum team, stakeholders, and other third parties to clear the way so that the developers can function unhindered.
If scrum masters have organizational clout, which is informal and a socially earned ability to influence, they can best serve their teams to optimize their working environment. In Chapter 2, we talked more about different types of clout. Provide training and mentorship to ensure that your scrum masters develop servant leadership skills and put off the tendencies of commanding and directing.
Want to go deeper? The science behind servant leadership…
Research consistently shows that teams led by servant leaders report higher trust, engagement, and performance. Servant leadership fosters psychological safety, allowing team members to experiment, share ideas, and resolve conflicts collaboratively, which is crucial in agile environments.
An approach where leaders focus on empowering and supporting their teams, rather than commanding or controlling them.
Informal, socially earned influence—distinct from formal authority—that enables a scrum master to clear obstacles and optimize team performance.
In many organizations, scrum masters without formal authority have successfully facilitated major process improvements simply by earning trust and demonstrating value. Their “clout” comes from relationships, not job titles.
How does informal influence change the way a scrum master interacts with their team and stakeholders?
- Scrum masters should empower teams rather than direct them.
- Clout is earned socially, not granted by title.
Identify signs of informal influence in your workplace.
- List three ways someone on your team influences others without formal authority.
- Discuss how these forms of clout help the team perform better.
Scrum masters need formal authority to be effective.
Scrum masters are most effective when they earn informal clout and practice servant leadership, not when they act as managers.
What are the risks of giving a scrum master formal authority over the team?
Experienced practitioners often note that mentoring and training are the keys to developing servant leadership skills, leading to greater team autonomy and trust.
Reflect on a time you saw someone leverage informal influence to achieve a goal. What made their approach successful, and how could you apply this to your role or team?
If you were a scrum master, how would you build your clout within a new team?
What is the most effective way for a scrum master to influence their team?
Scrum masters are most powerful when they earn informal clout and practice servant leadership, rather than relying on formal authority.
Training and mentorship are essential for developing the servant leadership skills that underpin effective scrum master influence.
Scrum masters should not be given formal authority but should rather be empowered by leadership to work with members of the scrum team, stakeholders, and other third parties to clear the way so that the developers can function unhindered.
The Shift
- Scrum masters achieve lasting influence through informal clout, not managerial authority.
- Servant leadership empowers teams to make decisions and work unhindered.
- Training and mentorship are vital for cultivating scrum master effectiveness.