Good GIS output isn’t just about creating maps and reports, it’s also about ensuring that your output is clear, useful, and accessible to your audience. Usability testing and feedback help you fine-tune your maps, reports, and apps so that they work seamlessly for your audience.
Many organizations skip user testing due to tight deadlines—but those that invest in feedback cycles often discover usability issues they never expected.
When I teach GIS or data visualization workshops, I always start with the importance of knowing your audience. I revisit and emphasize this point throughout the course because it’s so critical. So although I mention this idea earlier, it’s worth stressing it again: At the start of a project, you should have a good sense of your audience and their needs. Ongoing testing and user feedback help you stay aligned with those needs and guide improvements to ensure your project continues to meet them. This section offers tips on how to conduct usability testing, gather feedback from your audience, and update your GIS project based on the user input.
Think back to the last time you used a confusing map or digital tool. What was the single biggest obstacle you faced?
Conducting usability testing
Before sharing your outputs with the world, test them like you mean it! Usability testing involves observing how real users interact with your creation and identifying any issues. Whether you’re working on a printed map or an interactive app, the goal is the same: to ensure that your output works for your audience. Here are some best practices to keep in mind:
- Test with your audience in mind: Choose testers who match your audience — whether they’re planners, stakeholders, or constituents.
- Test for clarity: Ask users to identify key features or interpret patterns on your map. Do they understand the map without any explanation from you? Are any elements confusing or distracting?
- Focus on key tasks: Ask your testers to complete common tasks, like finding a specific location on a map or generating a report.
- Watch and learn: Pay attention to where users struggle. Are buttons hard to find? Is the interface too confusing? Take notes on what needs fixing, and fix it.
Sit quietly while your testers work and resist the urge to explain or help. Observing silently is the best way to get honest feedback.
Test your own map, app, or report with a friend or colleague to spot real-world usability issues.
- Choose someone who resembles your target audience.
- Give them a task (for example: “Find the nearest park on this map”).
- Observe silently and note where they struggle or get confused.
- Afterward, ask for their feedback and suggestions.
What is one simple change you could make to your GIS output to improve clarity for first-time users?
Want to go deeper? The science behind usability testing
Usability testing is rooted in cognitive psychology and human-computer interaction. Silent observation reveals gaps between how designers expect tools to be used and how people actually use them. Even a handful of real users can uncover most major usability issues. Iterative cycles—testing, updating, and retesting—deliver the best results for user-centered design.
Gathering feedback from diverse audiences
I had a professor in college who said, “There’s no such thing as the general public — it’s too broad of a term. Focus on specifics about your audience.” He was right. Although your audience may be diverse, they won’t have one-size-fits-all needs. Your job is to think about who your users are and tailor your outputs to their skill levels and expectations. Then gather meaningful feedback by
- Inviting a range of testers: Include users with different backgrounds, levels of GIS expertise, and accessibility needs aligned with your target audience.
- Asking the right questions: Focus on clarity, ease of use, and whether the output meets their needs. For example, you might ask:
- What did you find most helpful?
- What was confusing or frustrating?
- What would make this better for you?
- Providing different ways to give feedback: Use forms, surveys, or open forums for users to easily share their thoughts. For printed maps, you can include physical forms or host in-person focus groups.
In a city planning project, a GIS team invited both experienced planners and local residents to test an interactive zoning map. Residents spotted confusing color schemes planners hadn’t noticed, leading to a more accessible final product.
Why is it important to gather feedback from users with different backgrounds and skill levels?
A process where real users try out your product (such as a map or app) while you observe, to identify issues and opportunities for improvement.
- You’ve learned why testing with real users reveals issues you might overlook.
- You understand the importance of gathering feedback from a range of users—not just those most like you.
Iterating based on user input
Gathering feedback is just the first step. Acting on that input is what transforms good GIS output into great GIS output. Here’s how to continuously improve:
- Prioritize fixes. Address the most critical issues first, like improving text legibility on a printed map or fixing a broken link in an app.
- Keep improving. Even small tweaks, like changing font sizes, changing color palettes, or adding labels, can make a big difference in usability.
- Test again. After making updates, retest with users to ensure that the changes work as intended. For printed maps, this testing may simply involve printing a revised draft to verify improvements. For apps, it may mean another round of usability testing.
Think of your GIS output as a living document, always evolving and improving with user input. This approach doesn’t just create better maps; it builds trust and credibility with your audience.
Practitioners often keep a “feedback log” for each project, tracking what users report and how each issue was addressed over time.
Once I publish a map or app, my work is done.
GIS outputs should be continually updated and improved based on user feedback and evolving needs.
The process of repeatedly improving a product by making changes based on feedback and retesting.
Gathering and acting on user feedback transforms your GIS outputs from good to great, ensuring they remain clear, useful, and relevant.
“There’s no such thing as the general public — it’s too broad of a term. Focus on specifics about your audience.”
Usability testing with real users is essential for creating GIS outputs that truly serve the audience’s needs.
What is usability testing?
Tap to revealObserving real users as they interact with your GIS outputs to identify issues and improve usability.
Why is it important to gather feedback from diverse users?
Tap to revealDiverse users can reveal issues and needs you might otherwise overlook, leading to more accessible and effective GIS outputs.
What does it mean to iterate based on user input?
Tap to revealMaking improvements to your GIS outputs after collecting and analyzing feedback, then retesting to ensure effectiveness.
Describe a time when user feedback led you to make an important change in a project (GIS or otherwise). What did you learn from that experience?
Reflect on a GIS project or map you’ve created or used. How might you apply the process of usability testing and iteration to improve it?
How confident are you that you can plan and carry out usability testing for a GIS output?