A Changing Landscape in Publishing
Enormous rates of change are occurring. Brick-and-mortar bookstores are suffering, and readers have shifted ways of finding books and authors. Even libraries are receiving less funding, and much of their shelf space has been converted to computers and other media.
On top of this, readers can now choose between reading or listening on desktops, mobile platforms, and, decreasingly, traditional hardback and paperback books. Now, different media forms compete against each other for the same content.
Traditional revenue models are changing for advertising and subscriptions in this new publishing environment, so new models are needed to take advantage of this new digital world. But publishers are still discovering those models.
Fewer than 10% of Americans now buy books primarily at physical bookstores—digital channels and apps have transformed how readers discover new authors.
The music industry experienced a similar seismic shift. Traditional album buying flew out the door when iTunes flew in. Free and often illegal music downloads stirred up a fresh debate on copyright law (enriching scores of lawyers along the way), and avenues for music today are dramatically different from those 20 years ago. But new songs and albums are created all the time, and musical life goes on. It just looks different.
The same can be said of publishing. For some organizations, massive industry changes are terrifying; for others, opportunity is recognized, flexibility is sought, and inspection and adaptation are seen as paramount. Some publishers say that because of the rapid change, they’re not sure which data they should use to form their decisions. The sand is shifting under their feet.
Scrum can help the publishing industry flourish. The very qualities that so many people in the industry find unsettling — rapid change, shifting consumer needs and desires, and uncertain sources of revenue — are the ones in which scrum excels.
- Publishing is facing rapid, unpredictable change in technology and reader habits.
- Scrum’s core ideas of inspection, adaptation, and refactoring offer a solution.
An agile framework that emphasizes iterative development, rapid feedback, and adaptability to change.
The process of continuously evaluating work and making adjustments based on feedback.
Want to go deeper? The science behind rapid feedback in publishing
Psychological research shows that immediate feedback accelerates learning and drives motivation. In publishing, analytics tools that track reader engagement allow publishers and authors to refine content quickly, mirroring the principles of agile development. This real-time loop increases not only content quality but also the likelihood of commercial success, as it aligns product offerings with consumer demand.
Which changes in the publishing industry do you find most surprising, and why?
Inspecting, Adapting, and Refactoring
Inspection, adaptation, and refactoring are the heart of scrum, and they fit the world of publishing. Like each industry we cover in this book, publishing has its own set of challenges and scrum solutions.
Changing Readers
What readers expect from a book, magazine article, or newspaper feed is changing. Immediate information and instant gratification are the norm. Unless the author is already a huge best seller with a wide following, most readers won’t sit down to finish a 1,000-page tome.
A flood of data can be accessed by incorporating rapid feedback from readers via short articles, blogs, and analytical tracking tools for reader click-through rates and responses. The news media, publishers, and individual authors can quickly see what readers are responding to and adjust accordingly.
Not only does this rapid feedback cycle mean better content, but it also means faster monetization. As you inspect and adapt on the go, you can follow those paths that lead to more clicks and hits, incorporating more revenue streams through advertising and sales.
How do you think rapid feedback from readers is changing the way content is created and marketed?
Changing Writers
Brandon Sanderson, a sci-fi and fantasy author of the enormously popular books written in the Cosmere universe, broke records with his self-publishing Kickstarter campaign. The campaign was set up to raise $1 million within 30 days to fund four secret books written during the pandemic. It didn’t take 30 days to blow past that goal, though. It took only 35 minutes! After three days, he earned more than $20 million, beating the previous record and landing nearly $42 million after 30 days. The author told The New York Times one of his objectives was to see what it would be like to challenge Amazon.
Similarly, but no less impressive, Hugh Howey broke more than one mold with his New York Times best-selling novel Wool. He published the original short story on Amazon for 99 cents a copy and received such an overwhelmingly positive response that he kept on writing.
Howey wrote and self-published five serial stories, getting feedback from readers with each one, and combined them to create the book Wool Omnibus (self-published by Broad Reach Publishing). It landed on the Times best-seller list and created a sweet seven-figure revenue stream for him.
After self-publishing and reaching the best-seller list, Howey signed a contract with a traditional publishing firm, Simon & Schuster. In yet another mold-shattering move, he sold only the print rights to the publisher, keeping all digital rights and proceeds for himself.
Serial stories are produced in sprints. Feedback comes from readers and potential book buyers. Some authors use self-publishing, where each detail can be inspected and adapted along the way. Both success stories were unintentional variations of scrum.
Analyze how a recent bestseller adapted to feedback from readers or the market.
- Choose a popular book or author who has used reader feedback (e.g., via blogs, Kickstarter, or Amazon reviews).
- Identify one specific way they changed or adapted their work in response.
- Reflect: Did this adaptation help them succeed?
Changing Products
What and how people read and listen are in flux. Graphic novels, manga, and interactive serials combine with novels, audible books, articles, and blogs to create a wide net within which authors place their work. Add e-readers, smartphone apps, and steadily decreasing hardcopy numbers, and you have a changing world.
No author or reader is untouched by this literary revolution. T.S. Eliot’s classic epic poem “The Waste Land” has its own iPad app, but it isn’t just a copied-and-pasted edition of the text. The app incorporates these features:
- A filmed performance of the poem by Fiona Shaw
- Audio readings by T.S. Eliot and actors such as Alec Guinness and Viggo Mortensen
- Interactive notes to help the reader with cultural references and poetic nuances
- Videos of literary experts providing insight on the masterpiece
- Original manuscript pages that show the reader how the poem developed under the guidance of Ezra Pound
The publishers (Faber and Touch Press) aren’t sitting on the sidelines lamenting the good old days. They’re jumping right in and producing great art in new ways.
For publishers and authors alike, scrum’s feedback cycle allows for fast input and an accelerated time to market, creating products that customers want and will pay for. Those who embrace this change and incorporate empirical frameworks (such as scrum) that allow for this feedback cycle are excelling in this new environment.
“Survival of the fastest to change” is the mantra. See change as an opportunity, and you’ll come out on top.
Imagine you are a publisher: what would you do to stay ahead of changes in reader preferences and technology?
Publishing is a slow-moving industry that can’t adapt quickly to change.
With frameworks like scrum and digital tools, publishers and authors can rapidly inspect, adapt, and refactor their content and business models to thrive in a changing landscape.
Self-publishing platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct and Kickstarter campaigns empower authors to test new ideas, gather feedback, and launch products in weeks—not months or years.
A publisher’s ability to adjust product offerings based on reader analytics and trends is now as important as editorial expertise. Successful publishers use sprints to pilot new formats and monetize fresh channels.
“Survival of the fastest to change” is the mantra. See change as an opportunity, and you’ll come out on top.
Brandon Sanderson’s Kickstarter campaign
Tap to revealSanderson broke records by raising over $42 million to self-publish four books, showing the power of direct reader feedback and digital platforms.
Inspection and adaptation in publishing
Tap to revealContinuous evaluation and adjustment of content based on reader feedback and analytics, leading to improved quality and faster monetization.
Howey’s strategy with “Wool”
Tap to revealHugh Howey published serial stories, gathered feedback, and retained digital rights to maximize revenue and control.
Which scrum principle most directly enables publishers to respond quickly to changing reader preferences?
Reflect on a time when you encountered rapid change—either as a reader, writer, or publisher. How did adaptability (or lack thereof) impact the outcome?
Scrum’s principles of inspection and adaptation are precisely what publishers and authors need to navigate—and capitalize on—a rapidly shifting publishing landscape.
Embracing feedback cycles and empirical frameworks enables faster monetization and greater success in a digital world.
The shift in publishing echoes agile transformations in other industries, such as software and music, where rapid experimentation and adaptation drive success.
If you were launching a new book or media product today, what scrum-inspired tactics would you use to maximize reader engagement and revenue?
How confident are you that you can explain how scrum helps publishers adapt to rapid industry change?