Before you create a map—digital or hard copy—you need a clear sense of the geography you want to include. The elements you select for your map and GIS database will shape your entire analysis, and ultimately determine the quality of your results.
GIS isn’t just about visualizing spatial data—it’s about asking the right questions so your maps become powerful tools for decision-making, not just pretty pictures.
Whether you’re working with economic geography, medical geography, transportation geography, urban geography, or any other specialization, each type demands its own unique data and analysis approach. For example, imagine you’re using GIS to improve the productivity of your stores. You might consider:
- Economic geography: What is the average income of shoppers in your area?
- Transportation geography: How do people get to and from your stores?
- Physical geography: How do seasonal weather changes impact what customers buy?
Your mission is to select the geographies that fit your project best, and use them to build maps that drive meaningful outcomes.
- Geographic features and data selection form the foundation of every GIS analysis.
- Asking the right questions helps translate project goals into actionable map features.
Choosing the Data
One effective trick for deciding what data to include? Start at the end—imagine what you want your final map or analysis to look like. Suppose you’re using GIS to find the best location for a new housing development. Ask yourself:
- How big of a piece of land do I need?
- How much am I willing to pay for the land?
- Are there any locational constraints? Where do I prefer the land to be?
- What are the legal constraints—such as zoning and ownership—for developing the land?
- What physical constraints am I willing to accept?
- What are the infrastructure needs for this development?
Your answers will help you determine the data you’ll need for your GIS project. This might include:
- Parcel data to filter by size requirements.
- Current sale price or value of the land to find parcels within your price range.
- Features like hospitals, schools, parks to measure proximity.
- Local zoning data to verify residential zoning or identify zoning variances needed.
- Land ownership data to know whom to purchase from—or whether you can buy the land at all.
- Topography, soils, vegetation, bedrock, and other physical factors to estimate development work.
- Infrastructure data (power, water, broadband) to assess installation needs.
By starting at the end, you break your GIS project into manageable pieces. Asking the right questions about your needs translates directly into specific map features and data layers, keeping your project focused and your analysis relevant.
Which of the questions above would be most important if your GIS project was about public health, rather than housing?
Applying the Methodology
Even if your project isn’t about housing, the same principles apply. Whether you’re selecting the best location for a new store, choosing a wildlife preserve site, assessing crime hotspots, or predicting hazardous cargo spill risks—the question remains: Where? Location is the heart of every GIS project.
Major GIS projects revolve around the locations and distributions of features. Sometimes, you use GIS to describe impacts; other times, to decide where to locate businesses, services, or facilities. In every case, the methodology is the same: define your needs and break the data into manageable chunks.
No matter the topic, the best place to start is the end. Visualizing your final result helps you identify the relevant parts of your project and plan your data collection accordingly.
City planners use GIS to determine where to build parks and playgrounds, considering everything from land availability to proximity to neighborhoods and infrastructure needs. Starting at the end—imagining the ideal park and its location—guides their data selection.
Think about a recent map you used. What data layers do you think were prioritized—and why?
Breaking Down the Data
Practitioners often use attribute tables in GIS to filter and analyze locations—not just by geography, but by linked details like ownership, zoning, or utility access. This allows for more nuanced, actionable insights.
Each data layer you select for your GIS database includes not just the geographic features, but also the information—or attributes—tied to those features. Sometimes you need all the attributes; other times, only a few are relevant.
Let’s revisit the housing development example. A soils data layer might contain useful attributes for construction suitability, but also include irrelevant details like soil names or classifications. Focus on the attributes that matter for your project.
Outline your project’s details and ask specific data-related questions: What are the requirements for your ideal parcel—size, price, location, access to utilities? Breaking these into smaller chunks makes them easier to manage.
Suppose you’re also aiming to create a bird sanctuary near the development. You’ll need land that meets unique requirements. Useful data layers might include:
- Land ownership: Identify who owns the land—exclude government parcels, focus on private land for purchase.
- Land for sale: See parcel sizes and prices, aiming for a 20-acre parcel under $2,000 per acre.
- City limits: Ensure the sanctuary is within five miles of the town using boundary data.
- Transportation: Confirm access via roads or highways.
- Utilities: Check proximity to electricity, gas, and water.
Visual tools like flowcharts help break down these requirements step by step. Each component feeds into your final product—the bird sanctuary.
All map data is equally important—just include everything you can find.
Only the data relevant to your project’s goals and questions should be included; focus prevents confusion and makes your GIS analysis actionable.
Information tied to a geographic feature in GIS, such as ownership, zoning, or utility access.
A distinct set of geographic features and their associated attributes, used in GIS for analysis and mapping.
Location is the core of every GIS project.
Want to go deeper? The science behind data selection in GIS
Data selection in GIS isn’t just about collecting as much information as possible—it’s about identifying which layers and attributes directly support your analysis goals. The process often involves filtering out noise, using statistical methods or expert judgment to prioritize data that influences outcomes. If you’re mapping disease outbreaks, for example, demographic and environmental data may be vital, while unrelated land use layers might distract from actionable insights.
Pick a project idea—a new park, store, or wildlife preserve. List at least five types of data layers you would need, and write one question for each layer that helps guide your analysis.
- Choose your project type.
- Brainstorm five relevant data layers.
- For each, write a guiding question (e.g., “How close is the parcel to schools?”).
- Share your list with a peer or reflect on which layers seem most crucial.
After listing your data layers, which ones would you prioritize—and why?
What does “starting at the end” mean in GIS project planning?
Tap to revealIt means visualizing the final outcome first, then working backward to identify the data and features needed for your GIS project.
What are GIS data layers?
Tap to revealCollections of geographic features and their associated attributes, organized for mapping and analysis.
Why is attribute selection important when building a GIS database?
Tap to revealBecause only attributes relevant to your project’s goals will make your analysis effective and meaningful.
What is the first step recommended when deciding which data to include in a GIS project?
Imagine a GIS project for your local community. What would your “end result” look like—and how would you break down the data layers and attributes needed to achieve it?
The most effective GIS projects start by visualizing the final result, then breaking down the data and attributes needed to achieve that goal.
Only data relevant to your project’s questions and objectives should be included in your map—focus supports clarity and actionable analysis.
Spatial analysis techniques, like buffer zones and proximity measurements, depend on selecting the right data layers for your GIS maps.
How confident are you that you can break down a GIS project into relevant data layers and attributes?
The Shift
- Start GIS projects by visualizing the end result and working backward to define data needs.
- Focus on collecting and mapping only the data layers and attributes relevant to your project goals.
- Breaking down complex projects into manageable questions and data components keeps your GIS analysis clear and actionable.