How can GIS overlay tools help you discover meaningful spatial relationships between different types of geographic data?
Layering data is one of GIS’s primary functions. An overlay tool lets you visualize different types of data together, like city points connected by road lines within state polygon boundaries. These layers are great for creating a state road map with major cities highlighted, but what if you want to compare the layers against each other?
- Transportation: How many miles of roads (lines) does a state (polygon) transportation department need to maintain?
- Water studies: How many wells (points) are inside a particular county (polygon)?
Overlay methods in GIS are not just for visualization—they’re fundamental for spatial analysis in fields like epidemiology, urban planning, and environmental science.
GIS overlay tools help you analyze spatial relationships between different data layers. The basic methods described in this lesson, Select by Location and Spatial Join, are ideal when you need quick results or are prepping your data for further analysis.
When using overlay tools, most GIS software automatically adjusts the display of data layers that have different coordinate systems so that they align correctly on your map. Even though this adjustment happens automatically, it’s still good practice to check that all your layers have the correct coordinate system.
GIS professionals often use overlay methods to quickly identify spatial trends, such as which neighborhoods are at risk during a flood or where infrastructure should be prioritized for maintenance.
Selecting by Location
When you need an answer to something like “What’s near what?” or “What’s inside what?” the Select by Location tool is the tool of choice. It’s a quick and easy way to highlight (select) features that meet spatial criteria without creating a new layer or dataset.
For example, if you’re working with a city planning office, you may be tasked with identifying all the businesses within a flood zone. You use GIS to select all the businesses (points) that fall within the flood zone (polygon). Now you can use those selected points to generate a quick report or simply visualize the results on a map to start thinking about your next steps.
How might selecting features by location help a city planner prioritize emergency response actions?
A GIS tool used to highlight features in one layer based on their spatial relationship to features in another layer, without creating a new dataset.
Practice using the Select by Location tool in your GIS software.
- Open a GIS project with a layer of point features (e.g., businesses) and a polygon layer (e.g., flood zone).
- Use the
Select by Locationtool to select all points that fall within the polygon. - View the selected points and consider what actions might follow from this analysis.
Emergency management teams use Select by Location to quickly identify residents or assets inside hazardous zones during natural disasters.
- ArcGIS Pro: Choose the
Select by Locationtool in theSelectiongroup of theMaptab. Choose your input layer, specify the relationship (like “Within a distance,” “Contains,” or “Intersects”), and run the tool to highlight the matching features. - QGIS: Choose the
Select by Locationtool found on the project toolbar or from theVectormenu and go toResearch Tools > Select by Location. Set your target and source layers, specify the relationship (like “Intersect,” “Contain,” or “Overlap”), and run the tool to select features.
Selecting features by location is great for highlighting features on the fly. But if you find yourself needing a new layer that combines attributes from overlapping or nearby features, use a spatial join instead.
What are the advantages of using Select by Location for exploratory analysis compared to creating a new dataset?
Performing Spatial Joins
When you need to transfer attributes from one layer to another based on their location to each other, you want to use the spatial join tool. This tool creates a new layer with the combined attributes, which is a classic use of GIS.
For example, suppose you’re studying burrowing owl nests. You have a point layer of the nests and want to add details about the parks (polygons) where the nests are located. A spatial join makes adding these details easy. By joining the park polygons to the owl nest points, you create a new point layer. In this new layer, each nest point includes the attributes for the park and where it’s located, such as the park’s name or size.
A GIS process that creates a new layer by combining the attributes of two layers based on their spatial relationship.
- ArcGIS Pro: Choose the
Spatial Jointool found on theAnalysistab (or in theOverlaytoolset of theAnalysis Toolstoolbox). Choose the target and join layers, define the relationship, and specify the output layer. - QGIS: Choose the
Join Attributes by Location tool, found inData Management Toolson theVectormenu orVector Generalin theProcessing Toolbox. Choose the layers and the spatial relationship, and specify an output layer or create a temporary layer (the default).
When performing a spatial join, be sure you’re using the right spatial relationship for the job. “Contains” and “Intersects,” two of the most common spatial relationships, will give you different results, so choose carefully to make sure that your output layer has the connections you’re looking for. If you’re unsure, run both and compare the results to find the one that fits your needs.
How might spatial joins help an environmental scientist analyze the impact of parks on local wildlife populations?
Want to go deeper? The science behind spatial relationships
Spatial relationships in GIS are defined mathematically, often using geometry and topology. Common relationships include “contains,” “intersects,” and “within a distance.” These determine how features from different layers interact and are foundational for spatial analysis. Understanding which relationship to select is crucial for accurate results—misselecting can lead to misinterpretation of patterns and connections.
- Learned how Select by Location highlights data based on spatial criteria.
- Discovered how Spatial Join combines layer attributes for deeper analysis.
GIS overlay tools are only useful for visualizing maps, not for analysis.
Overlay methods such as Select by Location and Spatial Join are powerful analytical tools that help answer complex spatial questions and drive data-informed decisions.
GIS overlay tools help you analyze spatial relationships between different data layers.
What does the Select by Location tool do?
Tap to revealIt selects features from one layer based on their spatial relationship to features in another layer, without creating a new dataset.
What is a Spatial Join in GIS?
Tap to revealA process that creates a new layer by combining attributes from two layers based on their spatial relationship.
Why is it important to check the coordinate system of your layers?
Tap to revealTo ensure all data layers align properly on your map and avoid errors in spatial analysis.
Overlay tools in GIS like Select by Location and Spatial Join empower users to analyze and combine spatial data, revealing relationships that drive meaningful decisions.
Choosing the correct spatial relationship is crucial for accurate GIS analysis and results.
Think of a real-world scenario where combining spatial attributes from two layers could lead to important insights. How would you use overlay tools to find those insights?
What challenges might arise when combining layers with different coordinate systems, and how can they be addressed?
The Shift
- Overlay tools like Select by Location and Spatial Join are essential for spatial analysis, not just visualization.
- Choosing the right spatial relationship determines the accuracy and relevance of GIS results.
- Combining spatial attributes helps uncover patterns and relationships that inform real-world decision-making.