How can developers accurately estimate the effort required for each item in a product backlog, setting the stage for successful Scrum sprints?
Imagine embarking on a large project without a clear sense of how much work lies ahead. In Scrum, backlog estimation gives your team a crucial edge, helping to forecast, plan, and adapt as development unfolds. But what’s the secret to effective estimation—and why does it matter so much?
Many successful Scrum teams revisit their backlog estimates regularly, using them as learning tools to improve future predictions and team cohesion.
In creating the product roadmap, the developers do a high-level estimate of the amount of work entailed in the product. The practical value of this estimation process doesn’t come into play until the sprints start, but this initial estimation sets a mark from which future estimates may be calculated. The developers do the estimating because only the people who do the work should estimate the effort of the work.
These backlog estimation techniques aren’t requirements of scrum. They’re common practices scrum practitioners have found useful in the field.
Seasoned Scrum practitioners often adapt their estimation techniques based on project complexity and team experience, blending established practices with team-specific adjustments.
Why do you think it’s important that only developers, not managers or stakeholders, estimate the effort of backlog items?
The product roadmap is the start of the product backlog. What’s on your roadmap is what you will begin developing. So, how do you take all those items on your product backlog and estimate the work involved with any degree of accuracy? A few common practices are used depending on the situation. Before we look at these estimating techniques individually, it’s important to understand what you’re trying to achieve.
How might inaccurate backlog estimates affect the flow and outcomes of your Scrum sprints?
A prioritized list of all work items, features, and requirements for a product, maintained and refined throughout development in Scrum.
A high-level visual summary that maps out the product’s vision and direction, serving as the foundation for the product backlog.
At a leading software company, teams regularly review their product roadmap and refine their backlog estimates, allowing them to adapt quickly when priorities shift or new information emerges.
Want to go deeper? The science behind estimation accuracy
Studies have shown that estimation is more accurate when those closest to the work—namely, the developers—own the process. Cognitive bias, team culture, and experience all influence how accurately teams can forecast their work. Over time, reflecting on estimation accuracy can reveal valuable patterns that help teams calibrate future estimates and improve sprint planning.
Backlog estimation is a rigid requirement in Scrum and must follow a specific process.
Scrum does not mandate any particular estimation technique; teams adopt the approaches that best fit their unique needs and experience.
The developers do the estimating because only the people who do the work should estimate the effort of the work.
- Understood why backlog estimation sets the foundation for future planning in Scrum
- Recognized that estimation techniques are common practices, not requirements
Practice backlog estimation by choosing three simple tasks and discussing their effort.
- List three tasks from a recent project or daily routine.
- Estimate the relative effort for each task (e.g., easy, medium, hard).
- Reflect on what influenced your estimates and how you might adjust them if you learned new information.
What factors might cause two developers to estimate the same backlog item differently?
Who is responsible for estimating the effort of backlog items in Scrum?
Tap to revealThe developers—only those who will do the work should estimate its effort.
Is backlog estimation a required part of Scrum?
Tap to revealNo. Estimation techniques are common practices, not formal requirements of Scrum.
What does the initial estimation during the product roadmap help with?
Tap to revealIt sets a baseline for calculating future estimates as the work progresses.
Reflect on a time when you were part of a team estimating work. What challenges did you face, and how could Scrum’s approach to backlog estimation have helped?
Backlog estimation is most effective when done by those who will perform the work, using techniques that fit the team—setting a foundation for accurate planning and successful sprints.
Estimation methods in Scrum are flexible practices rather than strict rules, empowering teams to choose what works best for their context.
What benefits do you see in revisiting and updating backlog estimates as a project progresses?
The Shift
- Backlog estimation is a flexible, team-driven practice, not a rigid Scrum rule.
- Accurate estimation sets the groundwork for effective planning and adaptive sprints.
- Reflecting on and refining estimates over time leads to stronger teamwork and project outcomes.